• Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer
Get Updates

Vouchers Hurt Ohio

When we let vouchers drain our schools, it hurts us all.

  • About VHO
  • How to Join
  • Participating Districts
  • Book: Right Down the Drain
  • FAQs

pnmadmin

Nov 17 2026

VHO at OSBA

Good Tuesday morning,

We’re so pleased to once again attend the Ohio School Boards Association (OSBA) Capital Conference and Trade Show in Columbus.

On Monday (yesterday), we had a packed house attend our session: EdChoice voucher litigation moves toward the finish line.

School board members are fired up and wanted information about how to join our lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of the harmful EdChoice private school voucher system.

William L. Phillis, with VHO and the Coalition for Equity & Adequacy of School Funding, told the packed crowd we’re 2-0 with one to go now that the 10th District Court of Appeals unanimously ruled EdChoice vouchers unconstitutional in October following the June, 2025 decision by Franklin County Common Pleas Judge Jaiza Page.

Former Ohio Supreme Court Chief Justice Eric Brown, who chairs the VHO Steering Committee, said he was confident the justices on the Supreme Court would follow the law and the Ohio Constitution now that the case has been appealed to them.

Dan Heintz, a board member with Cleveland Heights-University Heights and a teacher in Chardon, told board members they were standing up for taxpayers in their communities by joining the lawsuit because the state was shortchanging public schools to give rebates and refunds to wealthy parents whose children were already enrolled in private, mostly religious schools.

Miriam Fair, with Weston Hurde LLP, who is one of two lead attorneys for VHO and will argue our case before the Ohio Supreme Court, told the group the private school operators have all the power, not the parents or children, in deciding which children are admitted into their schools.

Stephen Dyer, a former Ohio House member who helped develop a constitutional funding formula adopted by Gov. Ted Strickland and then abandoned by Gov. John Kasich, told the group we have momentum on our side following the November elections.

Barbara Sykes, Akron City Schools Board President, said her board joined with the unions in her district to stand strong together against EdChoice vouchers and recommended that school boards do the same across the state.

Eric Resnick, former Canton City Schools board member who initiated the lawsuit, stood before the crowd and said we need to send a strong message to the Ohio Supreme Court of unity among districts so board members need to sign their school districts up for the lawsuit.

One board member stood among the crowd and asked: “Why isn’t every school district in the state part of this historic lawsuit?”

We’ll get to that in a moment.

We have a booth in the exhibition hall at 210 where you can grab a magnet, a button, and talk to someone about how EdChoice private school vouchers are hurting your community

You can also grab a copy of the book: Right Down The Drain, written by 12 doctoral students, and their professor, Thomas S. Poetter, in Education Leadership at Miami University, that exposes the issues and problems created by the EdChoice system that is draining billions of dollars away from public schools and public school children.

Now, back to that question: why isn’t every school district in the state part of our lawsuit?

We’ll talk more about this next week, but check here to see if your school district has joined.

If not, ask yourself why not? Why isn’t your district standing up for students, educators, your community, your taxpayers and public schools across Ohio? Learn how to join here.

Sincerely,

Vouchers Hurt Ohio

Written by pnmadmin · Categorized: Uncategorized

Nov 10 2026

When School Levies Fail

Good Tuesday morning,

We had a monumental election in our state and across the country last week.

We also had 134 school districts that had levies on the ballot here in Ohio.

To state the obvious, that’s a lot of levies.

The Ohio School Boards Association reports 72 levies passed and 62 failed.

The Columbus Dispatch reported that renewals “were particularly successful. Voters approved 51 of 63 renewal requests, including two that also reduced taxes, for an 81 percent passage rate. Requests for additional funding faced a much tougher electorate, with just 20 of 69 passing or 29 percent.”

Here are some sad headlines in the aftermath:

“These local school districts face uncertain futures after operating levies fail.”

In the above story, Fox News reported voters approved nearly two dozen levies for school districts in Cleveland and northeast Ohio, but levies failed in more than 16 school districts.

The story was the same in other parts of the state:

“9 school levies failed in Southwest Ohio. What’s next for the districts’ financial futures?”

From the story: Only three of 12 school tax levies on the November 2026 ballot in Southwest Ohio passed, meaning several districts will be forced to make some tough financial decisions.

There’s a reason so many school districts are forced to voters with levies.

State lawmakers shortchanged funding public schools at a constitutional level by $2.75 billion in the current two-year state budget, according to Policy Matters Ohio.

In Lorain County, a renewal levy for Clearview Local lost by 13 votes. It would have generated a little less than $550,000 a year for the district.

According to Policy Matters Ohio, if lawmakers would have funded their own Cupp Patterson Fair School Funding Plan, Clearview Local would have received $4.3 million more in state funding.

In nearby Amherst, voters turned down a levy that would have generated about $5.8 million a year.

Cupp Patterson would have meant $7.1 million in additional state funding for Amherst. Instead, lawmakers reduced funding to the school by $738,000 in the two-year state budget.

This is one of the reasons we’re challenging, successfully, the constitutionality of the EdChoice private school voucher system because at the same time lawmakers are shortchanging public schools by $2.75 billion they are giving nearly $2 billion to mostly wealthy families whose children were already enrolled in primarily religious private schools.

Vouchers hurt property owners and taxpayers.

From Policy Matters Ohio: Ohio’s legislature has repeatedly reduced the state share of public school funding, from a high of 47 percent in 1999 down to an estimated 32.2 percent for the 2026-27 school year. This reduction in state share means that property tax revenue accounts for an increasingly large portion of Ohio public school funding.

School districts face tough choices. Either make massive cuts in educational services or ask local taxpayers to pony up because the state is shirking it’s constitutional responsibility.

Is your school district part of our historic lawsuit? Check here.

If not, why not? Join here.

Sincerely,

Vouchers Hurt Ohio

Written by pnmadmin · Categorized: Uncategorized

Oct 27 2026

Goff Is Mere Guff

Good Tuesday morning,

Last week, we outlined how the 10th District Court of Appeals, in a 40-page opinion, ruled the $1 billion EdChoice private school voucher program unconstitutional on two counts.

It’s a good read and contains so much good information about why Vouchers Hurt Ohio that it is difficult to outline in a simple email.

Today, let’s just look at this issue presented by the other side that somehow the Ohio Supreme Court has already ruled vouchers constitutional because of an earlier ruling on the Cleveland Pilot Program. The so-called “Goff” case.

The 10th District takes Goff apart as an argument for the pro-voucher crowd just as Franklin County Common Pleas Judge Jaiza Page did in her ruling that EdChoice vouchers are unconstitutional.

“Unlike the Cleveland Pilot Program, which was limited to (Cleveland City Schools), EdChoice dramatically expanded the geographic scope of state-funded private-school tuition assistance by making vouchers available to students statewide,” the 10th District ruling notes.

Here is more from the ruling that you can read here.

“In Goff, the Supreme Court upheld the Cleveland Pilot Program on the grounds that it was a narrow, experimental program necessitated by and designed to address the unique and extraordinary failure of a single school district.  As the Supreme Court stated, “We fail to see how the School Voucher Program, at the current funding level, undermines the state’s obligation to public education.”

“Goff nevertheless drew a clear constitutional line in the sand.  

The Supreme Court acknowledged that while the Cleveland Pilot Program was constitutionally permissible under Ohio Const. art. VI, § 2 in its present form, “implicit within [Ohio Const. art. VI, § 2] is a prohibition against the establishment of a system of uncommon (or nonpublic) schools financed by the state. 

The Ohio Supreme Court then warned that “a greatly expanded School Voucher Program or similar program could damage public education” and, for that reason, “be subject to a renewed constitutional challenge.”

“In other words, Goff did not give the state a blank check to fund private education with taxpayer dollars.  Rather, it upheld the Cleveland Pilot Program as a limited response to an extraordinary circumstance, while expressly cautioning that a substantially expanded voucher system could violate the Ohio Constitution.”

The earlier versions of EdChoice were based on students attending “low-performing” schools. 

All that changed in 2013, when pro-voucher lawmakers expanded EdChoice available to all students based solely on income and not on their local districts, and then in 2023, after we filed our lawsuit, the income limits were lifted.

Millionaires, even billionaires like Les Wexner, were eligible to receive EdChoice vouchers.

“Like earlier expansions of the voucher program, the 2023 EdChoice Expansion did not create  a right for students to transfer between public schools within or outside their district, nor did it provide tutorial grants for students who remained in public schools,” the 10th District ruling states.

This was a diversion of tax dollars from public to private, mostly religious schools.

“Although the (Ohio) Supreme Court held that the program’s limited scope did not violate Ohio Const. art. VI, § 2, it cautioned that a voucher program any larger in size or scale may run afoul of the Ohio Constitution,” the 10th District ruling states.

The 10th District ruled EdChoice vouchers unconstitutional because they create a separate and unequal system of uncommon schools and they siphon tax dollars away from funding a public school system, in which 90 percent of students in Ohio attend, at a constitutional level.

The 10th District understood Goff was limited in scope so the judges wrote:

“The Supreme Court of Ohio in Goff foretold the possibility that someday a greatly expanded voucher program could create a competing system of uncommon schools. Today is that day.”

Goff is not the answer the pro-voucher crowd is seeking and to date, as noted by media in this state, they have yet to produce a constitutional argument justifying taking away billions of tax dollars from the underfunded public schools to pay mostly wealthy families to send their children to private, mostly religious schools.

Is your district part of our historic lawsuit? Check here.

If not, why not? Join the districts standing up for public schools, students, families, educators and taxpayers here.

Sincerely,

Vouchers Hurt Ohio

Written by pnmadmin · Categorized: Uncategorized

Oct 20 2026

We’re 2-0 – EdChoice Vouchers Unconstitutional

Good Tuesday morning,

Last Thursday, we made history in Ohio when the 10th District Court of Appeals unanimously ruled the $1 billion a year EdChoice private school voucher system is unconstitutional – again.

We’re 2-0 in the courts. The 10th District upheld Franklin County Common Pleas Judge Jaiza Page’s June 2025 ruling that found EdChoice unconstitutional.

The 10th District ruled EdChoice is unconstitutional on two counts, and in a very interesting decision, the judges did not rule on two other counts before them.

You can and should read it here.

Judge Leland eviscerates the paltry defense mounted by Ohio Attorney General Andy Wilson’s office (why tax dollars are being used to defend an unconstitutional system that takes tax dollars away from public schools is beyond us), and the well-heeled pro-voucher out-of-state attorneys who magically appear in any state where vouchers are challenged.

Here is what Appellate Judge David Leland, who wrote the opinion, and the 10th District said and didn’t say about our five original counts of unconstitutionality:

On Count 1, we maintain the Ohio Constitution is clear that the legislature shall secure a single system of common schools for the common good that is open to all children in the state. 

EdChoice private school vouchers create a separate and unequal system of uncommon schools open to a select few. The vast majority of these families are wealthy and their children were already enrolled in private schools so EdChoice is a refund or rebate program. One reporter last week called the EdChoice voucher a “coupon” for the rich.

The 10th District agreed with us, and Judge Page, on Count 1: Unconstitutional.

Judge Leland stated: “Given these facts, as applied to the meaning of the word “secure” as it was used in the 1850s, we conclude that EdChoice, as presently structured, secures a separate system of non-public schools contrary to the mandates of Ohio Const. art. VI, § 2. “

“Aside from the fact that EdChoice schools are not public schools, there are three ways in which they are uncommon: (1) EdChoice schools, not parents, choose which students to admit, (2) EdChoice schools are geographically isolated in the urban counties of the state, and (3) EdChoice schools are not subject to any meaningful state oversight,” Judge Leland wrote.

On Count 2, we maintain EdChoice private school vouchers divert tax dollars away from public schools. Pro-voucher lawmakers like House Speaker Matt Huffman have abandoned the idea of funding public schools at a constitutional level. Huffman calls the Cupp Patterson Fair School Funding Plan a “fantasy,” and ‘unsustainable,” and passed a budget that shortchanged public schools by $2.75 billion.

Judge Leland wrote the EdChoice private school voucher system impacts public schools in three ways: the state is prioritizing EdChoice funding while underfunding public schools, EdChoice private schools cherry-pick students from public schools, and EdChoice has a negative impact on the passage of local school levies. 

“These combined effects undermine the General Assembly’s constitutional obligation to secure a thorough and efficient system of common schools throughout the state. That the state is still funding public schools while also funding EdChoice does not cure the constitutional violation, especially at the breadth and scope of funding that EdChoice receives. EdChoice, as presently structured and funded, crosses the constitutional threshold by using state tax dollars to draw students and resources away from the public schools in order to sustain a separate system of participating non-public schools, leaving the public schools to bear obligations and financial hardships that private schools do not share. As such, the EdChoice program operates to deprive students of the thorough and efficient system of common schools mandated by Ohio Const. art. VI, § 2,” Judge Leland wrote.

The Supreme Court of Ohio in Goff foretold the possibility that someday a greatly expanded voucher program could create a competing system of uncommon schools. Today is that day,” Judge Leland wrote.

Wow. 

Now, the 10th District set aside two counts, and that may have a big impact on the constitutionality of EdChoice vouchers down the line, but this is enough for one day.

Next week, we’ll talk about those two counts, and a third count that Judge Page did not rule on in the lower courts.

If your school district is part of this historic lawsuit, thank you for standing up for students, parents, educators and taxpayers. Yes, taxpayers. Check here.

If not, why not? Join here.

Sincerely,

Vouchers Hurt Ohio

Written by pnmadmin · Categorized: Uncategorized

Oct 15 2026

10th District Court of Appeals Affirms EdChoice Private School Vouchers Unconstitutional

COLUMBUS – The 10th District Court of Appeals of Ohio today affirmed a lower court ruling that the EdChoice private school voucher system is unconstitutional.

“Today’s 10th District Court of Appeals decision is a victory for public schools, public school children, parents, local communities, and taxpayers. This is a $1 billion boondoggle for mostly religious schools, which decide who they let in and who they shut out. It’s a refund and rebate program for mostly wealthy families whose children were already enrolled in private schools. Local taxpayers are left holding the $2 billion bill. We’re elated that a second court has looked at the facts, and agreed EdChoice vouchers hurt Ohio and are unconstitutional,” said William L. Phillis, speaking on behalf of Vouchers Hurt Ohio and the Coalition for Equity & Adequacy of School Funding.

“Vouchers hurt Ohio. The Ohio Constitution is clear. Lawmakers should be using tax dollars to fund a single system of common schools open to all children. EdChoice vouchers create a separate, and unequal system of schools – one for the haves and one for the have nots. Today’s decision is a victory for public schools and all the children in this state,” said former Ohio Supreme Court Chief Justice Eric Brown, who chairs the Vouchers Hurt Ohio Steering Committee.

You can read the full ruling here.

The Ohio Coalition for Equity & Adequacy of School Funding is working with Vouchers Hurt Ohio, a growing coalition of more than 300 public school districts that have come together to sue the state over the unconstitutional and harmful private school voucher program.

Written by pnmadmin · Categorized: Uncategorized

  • Page 1
  • Page 2
  • Page 3
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Page 26
  • Go to Next Page »
Take Action
VHO Meeting ScheduleFind Your SchoolLearn How to Join

Footer

Vouchers Hurt Ohio

EdChoice Vouchers Have Been Declared Unconstitutional.Now let’s make sure they get rid of them.

  • About VHO
  • How To Join
  • Participating Districts
  • Sign Up for Updates
Sign up for Emails