• Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer
Get Updates

Vouchers Hurt Ohio

When we let vouchers drain our schools, it hurts us all.

  • About VHO
  • How to Join
  • Participating Districts
  • Book: Right Down the Drain
  • FAQs

pnmadmin

Oct 13 2026

10th District Court of Appeals Ruling – When Is It Coming

Good Tuesday morning,

It has been five months since three judges on the 10th District Court of Appeals held a hearing on our lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of the $1.7 billion EdChoice private school voucher scheme.

As we travel the state talking to Ohioans about why Vouchers Hurt Ohio, we are often asked when will the 10th District Court rule?

We don’t know, possibly sometime this year, or early next year, but we are confident we will win on more than one of the four counts before the court.

The state and intervenors – lawyers representing groups funded by out-of-state anti-public school millionaires and billionaires – appealed a decision by Judge Jaiza Page that found EdChoice vouchers unconstitutional on three counts:

Count 1: Lawmakers shall create a single system of common schools for the common good open to all children. Vouchers create a separate and unequal system of schools open only to those students admitted by private schools and, for the most part, whose families are wealthy and can afford to pay additional tuition.

Count 2: Lawmakers have failed to fund public schools at a constitutional level. Policy Matters Ohio reports lawmakers shortchanged public schools $3 billion in the current two-year state budget, and the state share of funding education has dropped from 49 percent in 1999 to 32 percent in the current school year. This shirking of responsibility often puts schools in a no win situation: make cuts or ask local homeowners to pass levies.

Count 3: The language in the Ohio Constitution could not be more clear: No religious sect or other sect shall ever have exclusive right to or control of any part of the school funds of the state. More than 90 percent of the private schools receiving the $1.7 billion are religious. Our constitutional delegates believed in the separation of church and state.

Why are we confident that we will win?

Well, to date, the pro-voucher crowd has been unable to muster an argument based on the language in the Ohio Constitution.

Why is that? Because they don’t have one.

There is nothing in the Ohio Constitution that permits lawmakers and the governor to take nearly $1 billion a year in tax dollars and give it to private, mostly religious, schools for mostly wealthy families. 

After the court hearing on May 12, Cleveland.com | The Plain Dealer summed up the defense’s lack of defense with this headline: Ohio’s School Voucher House of Cards is Collapsing in Court. The State’s Defense is Embarrassing!

They should be embarrassed.

Vouchers Hurt Ohio, students, parents, educators, homeowners, taxpayers, local public schools, and our communities.

Is your district part of our historic lawsuit? More and more local schools are signing on. Check here.

If not, why not? Join here.

Sincerely,

Vouchers Hurt Ohio

Written by pnmadmin · Categorized: Uncategorized

Oct 06 2026

The Power of the Town Hall

Good Tuesday morning,

Inside the safe hallways of the Ohio Statehouse, where lawmakers like House Speaker Matt Huffman believe they can “pretty much do what (they) want,” the pro-voucher gang can start to believe their own propaganda.

Contrast that with what is happening all across Ohio where pro-public school folks, in community after community, are starting to realize how much Vouchers Hurt Ohio, their schools, their children, their neighborhoods, their taxpayers, and on and on.

A recent town hall in Southwestern City Schools near Columbus brought out a group of proactive citizens to denounce vouchers.

Last week, in LaBrae in Trumbull County in northeast Ohio, and in Chillicothe in Ross County in south Central Ohio, neighbors gathered to learn more about the $1 billion EdChoice harmful private school voucher program.

The media is also catching on.

Kaylee Remington, a reporter for Cleveland.com | The Plain Dealer wrote recently about a virtual town hall in Cleveland, where Madelaine Matej McQueen, a budget research for Policy Matters Ohio, told the gathered crowd that state lawmakers shortchanged public schools $2.75 billion in the current two-year state budget when they abandoned the Cupp Patterson Fair School Funding Plan.

“For example, under a fully implemented formula, Parma City Schools would have received roughly $9.7 million more, while the Cleveland Metropolitan School District’s funding gap was estimated at $157 million,” wrote Remington.

Parents talked about how their special education children were suffering as public schools are shortchanged, and programs for their children are cut while wealthy parents whose children were already in private schools are getting a rebate with the EdChoice voucher.

Read the full story here.

The headline: Parents, educators say Ohio public schools funding challenges are hitting hard in local classrooms.

The next day, cleveland.com | The Plain Dealer revisited the issue in their daily podcast with a much harder-hitting headline: ‘You didn’t fool anybody:’ Ohio families see through legislative attack on public schools”

Read the story here.

“I love this hearing because it shows you didn’t fool anybody,” host and Editor Chris Quinn said of the lawmakers who are crippling public schools. “They’re on to you.”

Yes, we are on to you and more and more Ohioans are becoming “on to you.”

This is why we are suing and winning in the court of law and in the court of public opinion.

Is your district part of our historic lawsuit to protect public schools and taxpayers? Check here.

If not, why not? Join here.

Sincerely,

Vouchers Hurt Ohio

Written by pnmadmin · Categorized: Uncategorized

Sep 29 2026

Are you following us on social media?

Good Tuesday afternoon,

We need your help, and it’s so easy.

If you follow us, and interact with us, on social media, you help spread the word about how EdChoice private school vouchers are hurting our public schools, our students, our communities, our taxpayers and our state.

Follow us on Facebook here.

On X (Twitter) here.

On Instagram here.

See, that wasn’t so hard.

And when you are on those platforms, interact with us so that our reach extends to others like you who are standing up for public schools.

Sincerely,

Vouchers Hurt Ohio

Written by pnmadmin · Categorized: Uncategorized

Sep 23 2026

The Greater Western Reserve School Funding Forum

Good Tuesday morning,

A week from tonight, on Tuesday September 29, the LaBrae Local School District in Trumbull County is hosting the Greater Western Reserve School Funding Forum.

We imagine you are going to see more and more of these local forums popping up around the state.

At LaBrae, this is an opportunity for local parents, taxpayers, property owners, community members and leaders to hear an expert panel talk about how state and local policies are affecting our public schools, our pocketbooks, our wallets and our local taxes.

The program will start at 6:30 p.m. in the LaBrae High School Auditorium.

And it is a great program.

The Patterson in the Cupp Patterson Fair School Funding Plan, former state Rep. John Patterson, will kick off the evening with help from Ryan Pendleton, a found member of the workgroup that developed the constitutional formula for ensuring every child in Ohio has a high quality education.

Patterson and Pendleton will discuss Fair School Funding – Then & Now, and it will surely look at the pro-voucher lawmakers in Columbus who abandoned their own formula and denied local public schools nearly $3 billion in the current two-year state budget.

Next up on the agenda: Ohio Tax Reform, a discussion of local taxes with a panel consisting of Ryan Ghizzoni of Frontline, Katie Johnson, executive director of the Ohio Association of School Business Officials, and Terry Armstrong, treasurer of the Lakeview Local School District.

Then former state Rep. Stephen Dyer will give an update on the current EdChoice private school voucher program and the footprint it is having on schools and property owners, and William L. Phillis will talk about our lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of EdChoice vouchers.

It will be a great evening of discussion and the event is free and open to the public.

The host is expecting to see folks from Trumbull, Mahoning, Portage and Ashtabula counties, and anyone considered part of the Western Reserve is encouraged to attend.

As we mentioned, there are forums like this being held all across the state.

For example, on the same evening, the League of Women Voters of Chillicothe is holding a public school forum in Ross County.

Here’s what happens when people find out the legislature shortchanged public schools $3 billion in the two-year budget while siphoning off nearly $2 billion to private school vouchers that are going mainly to wealthy families whose children were already enrolled in mainly religious schools: They get enraged and they then start to get engaged.

Is your district part of our historic lawsuit? Check here.

If not, why not? Why isn’t your local school board, treasurer and superintendent standing up for your community, your children, your public schools and local taxpayers? Learn how to join here.

Sincerely,
Vouchers Hurt Ohio

Written by pnmadmin · Categorized: Uncategorized

Sep 15 2026

Meet Dan Heintz

Good Tuesday morning,

We are winning in the court of law and we continue to win in the court of public opinion because we have great people on our side who put so much time and effort into helping to inform Ohioans about the harmful impact of EdChoice private school vouchers.

Meet Dan Heintz.

Dan is a teacher at Chardon High School. He is a school board member at Cleveland Heights-University Heights. And he is a fighter for public schools.

Dan has helped Vouchers Hurt Ohio in so many ways.

Dan’s district lost $27 million to vouchers so they had to ask voters twice to approve levies. As Dan was going door-to-door, voters in his district thanked him for standing up for their schools and their property taxes by opposing vouchers.

Dan was asked to debate the issue representing public schools against an advocate for vouchers. Three pro-voucher people turned down the chance to debate and so Dan appeared alone and schooled the audience on harmful vouchers.

The pro-voucher crowd was smart to avoid him.

Dan has traveled the state talking to teachers, active and retired, and appearing before school boards.

He was in Wilmington in southeast Ohio recently. Here is a great story about his appearance before the board that ran in the Wilmington News Journal. 

From the article: 

“Heintz outlined the constitutional foundation of the coalition’s case, centering on Article VI, Section 2 of the Ohio Constitution. The 52-word clause mandates that the General Assembly maintain a “thorough and efficient system of common schools throughout the state” and bars any “religious or other sect” from having exclusive control or rights to state school funds.

Data from the Ohio Department of Education and Workforce indicates individual vouchers provide up to $6,166 annually for a K-8 student and up to $8,408 for a high school student for the 2025-26 school year. By comparison, Wilmington City Schools receives roughly $5,300 per pupil in state funding, matching the Ohio Legislative Service Commission’s projected $5,308 per student for 2025.

Heintz used enrollment figures from Wilmington Christian Academy to illustrate the local dynamic, stating that the example was intended to explain funding mechanics rather than criticize the school.

Department of Education and Workforce data presented by Heintz showed Wilmington Christian Academy received nearly $2 million in voucher funding in fiscal year 2025 across 330 of its 334 enrolled students. He added that the academy also receives more than $900 per pupil through Ohio’s Auxiliary Services program, which directs separate state money to chartered nonpublic schools.

Since 2018, the school has received more than $6.8 million in voucher funding and an additional $600,000 in auxiliary services support, paid through state tax revenues, Heintz said.

He noted that enrollment at schools like Wilmington Christian did not surge in proportion to the increase in vouchers following the 2023 universal expansion, suggesting that many vouchers subsidized students already enrolled in private institutions rather than new transfers from public schools.”

It’s hard to argue with the facts and the fact is Vouchers Hurt Ohio, hurt our children, our teachers, our communities and our taxpayers.

Last night, Monday, September 14, Dan appeared before the Pickerington School Board just east of Columbus, and he was well received as he explained how Vouchers Hurt Pickerington.

Thank you Dan!

If you want Dan or another representative of Vouchers Hurt Ohio to appear before your school board, send an email to ohioeanda@sbcglobal.net.

Is your district part of our historic lawsuit? Check here.

If not, why not? Join here.

Sincerely,

Vouchers Hurt Ohio

Written by pnmadmin · Categorized: Uncategorized

  • « Go to Previous Page
  • Page 1
  • Page 2
  • Page 3
  • Page 4
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Page 26
  • Go to Next Page »
Take Action
VHO Meeting ScheduleFind Your SchoolLearn How to Join

Footer

Vouchers Hurt Ohio

EdChoice Vouchers Have Been Declared Unconstitutional.Now let’s make sure they get rid of them.

  • About VHO
  • How To Join
  • Participating Districts
  • Sign Up for Updates
Sign up for Emails